top of page

Why Therapy with Insurance Can be a Total Headache - Exploring the Downside of Using Insurance for Therapy

Writer: Brian SharpBrian Sharp

When it comes to therapy, many people often assume that using their insurance is the best way to make mental health care affordable. While insurance can help with some costs, it often brings along a host of challenges. This post will explore the downsides of using insurance for therapy, helping you make informed choices about your mental health care and finances.


The Limited Choice of Providers


Using insurance for therapy frequently limits your options when it comes to providers. Insurance companies have a network of approved therapists, which can be quite small. A recent survey revealed that nearly 40% of individuals seeking therapy face delays of three weeks or more to get an appointment with an in-network provider. This limitation might result in missing out on finding a therapist who specializes in your specific issues, such as anxiety or trauma.


Imagine trying to manage stress after a significant life event but only being able to see a therapist who focuses on family counseling. This mismatch can hinder your healing process and force you to stick with a therapist who may not fully meet your needs.


Complicated and Confusing Billing Processes


Understanding your insurance coverage can be a daunting task. You'll need to navigate through terms like deductibles, co-pays, and co-insurance, which can vary widely. A staggering 70% of patients report feeling confused about their mental health benefits. Billing for therapy is not always straightforward either.


For instance, if your therapist’s billing system doesn’t align with your understanding of your policy, you might encounter unexpected costs—especially right when you're trying to focus on your mental health. This can add stress instead of alleviating it.


Restrictions on Therapy Sessions when Using Insurance for Therapy

Stacks of overlapping white paper sheets filling the frame, creating a dense, textured pattern. No visible text or background elements.
A towering stack of paperwork symbolizes the overwhelming stress of managing insurance documents.

Many insurance plans impose limits on the number of therapy sessions they will cover, often capping it at just 12 sessions per year. Mental health recovery is rarely straightforward. What if you find a therapist who resonates with you, only to learn insurance will only fund a limited few visits? That could lead to tough financial decisions. With mental health challenges that often require ongoing support, this restriction can prove to be a significant barrier.


Stigma and Privacy Concerns


Utilizing insurance for therapy means sharing sensitive information with your provider, including diagnosis codes and treatment details. This disclosure can feel invasive and raise privacy concerns. A survey found that 54% of individuals may hesitate to seek therapy due to fears around confidentiality and stigma. The thought of personal mental health information being accessed by third parties can often deter people from getting the support they deserve, leaving them in silence when they need help the most.


Lack of Control Over Treatment Plans


When insurance is involved, external influences sometimes impact your treatment plan. Insurance companies often dictate which treatments are deemed “medically necessary,” which can limit your choices. For example, if you strongly prefer cognitive behavioral therapy, but your insurance covers only exposure therapy, you may be pushed toward a method that does not fit your needs. This misalignment can compromise the effectiveness of the care you receive.


The Neglect of Holistic Approaches


Insurance tends to favor traditional treatment methods and may not cover alternative therapies. For example, art therapy or mindfulness sessions can be incredibly beneficial, but they often fall outside the coverage provided by most insurance plans. In a 2022 study, nearly 62% of individuals reported that they sought holistic approaches but found them unaffordable due to lack of coverage. If you know that certain non-traditional methods are effective for you, being restricted to conventional therapy can feel frustrating.


Prolonged Claims Process


Another common issue is the slow claims process. Patients report that it can take several weeks or longer to get reimbursed after attending therapy sessions. This delay can be financially burdensome and stressful, especially when you need that support quickly. The need to repeatedly follow up and provide paperwork can turn what should be a healing experience into a complicated ordeal.


The Pressure of Accountability


Insurance companies require therapists to regularly justify the ongoing necessity of treatment. This can create an environment of pressure and stress. Your therapist may need to write extensive documentation and undergo reviews, which could divert their focus away from your healing. The therapeutic relationship should emphasize trust and care, not the burdens of insurance policies.


Potential for Increased Out-of-Pocket Costs


Surprisingly, using insurance does not always guarantee lower costs. Many people face high deductibles and co-pays. In fact, individuals may find themselves owing $75-$150 per session after reaching their deductible. As therapy sessions add up, this financial strain can become overwhelming and distract from the healing work you are trying to do.


Limited Flexibility in Scheduling


Flexibility in appointment times is crucial for many individuals. However, providers within insurance networks often have rigid schedules. For those with unconventional work hours or caregiving duties, finding a suitable therapist can be a challenge. A lack of flexible scheduling can hinder your ability to stick with therapy, prolonging your path to mental health.


Weighing Your Options


Using insurance to cover therapy can seem appealing, but the challenges often overshadow the benefits. From limited provider choices to complicated billing, session restrictions, privacy concerns, and financial pressures, hurdles can accumulate.


Therefore, as you consider using insurance for therapy, take a moment to explore all your options. Evaluate what's essential for your mental health care and know that your well-being should always take precedence.

Comments


Brian Sharp Counseling LLC

© 2023 by Brian L. Sharp, LPC-S, LPC, LMHC, NCC - Proudly created with Wix.com

Please note that visiting or subscribing to Brian Sharp Counseling, LLC does not constitute a counseling relationship. By using this website, you agree to hold harmless Brian Sharp Counseling, LLC and its representatives from any liability in connection with any decisions you may make in connection with your use of this website. If you are currently experiencing a mental health emergency, please do not use this website and instead contact 911, 988 or your nearest hospital emergency room for assistance.

Online therapy and counseling services available in Texas, Florida, Connecticut and the United Kingdom

Note: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.​

bottom of page