top of page

Stop "Shoulding" on Yourself and Others: How REBT Can Transform Your Perspective

Writer's picture: Brian SharpBrian Sharp

Have you ever found yourself thinking, "I should really be more productive," or "They should know better"? If so, you're not alone! Many of us get trapped in the cycle of "shoulding" on ourselves and others. This kind of thinking creates unrealistic expectations that weigh us down and diminish our happiness. It stifles growth and prevents us from adapting to life's challenges.


In this post, we will explore how Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy (REBT) can help you shift your focus and develop healthier, more flexible preferences. Spoiler alert: letting go of "shoulds" can lead to a happier, more fulfilling life!


What Does "Shoulding" Mean?


"Shoulding" is the habit of imposing obligations or expectations on ourselves or others using the word "should." This mindset often leads to feelings of guilt, frustration, and disappointment when reality doesn’t align with our expectations.


For example, telling yourself, "I should exercise more" highlights what you're not doing, reinforcing feelings of inadequacy. Similarly, saying, "They should be more considerate" places an unfair expectation on someone else. This kind of language creates a cycle of negativity that can be hard to break.


The Impact of “Shoulding”


The consequences of "shoulding" can be quite serious:


Pressure and Anxiety


The "shoulds" create unnecessary pressure. Constantly reminding yourself of what you ought to do can build anxiety and feelings of being overwhelmed.


For instance, a survey found that 80% of people feel anxiety about their workloads, often exacerbated by self-imposed expectations. This pressure can lead to impulsive actions like procrastination or overcommitting—neither of which is healthy for your mental well-being.


Resentment Towards Others


"Shoulding" can also foster resentment toward others. When you think someone "should" act a certain way and they don't, feelings of anger or disappointment often arise. This mindset can poison personal and professional relationships, leading to conflict.


Stagnation and Frustration


Lastly, being fixated on rigid "shoulds" can obstruct personal growth. It causes you to overlook opportunities and remain stuck in negative thought patterns.


What is REBT?


Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy (REBT) is a form of cognitive behavioral therapy developed by psychologist Albert Ellis in the 1950s. Its core idea is that it’s not the events in our lives that cause distress but our beliefs about those events.


REBT emphasizes identifying irrational thoughts, challenging them, and replacing them with more rational alternatives. This approach can lead to healthier emotional responses and behaviors.


Key Principles of REBT


  1. ABC Model: The ABC model helps you understand the connection between Activating events, Beliefs, and Consequences. By identifying the misguided beliefs from "shoulding," you can reshape how you respond.


  2. Disputing Irrational Beliefs: This principle encourages you to question your "shoulds." What evidence supports or contradicts these obligations? This process shows you that many of your "shoulds" are often unfounded.


  3. Emotional Regulation: By realizing that emotions stem from beliefs, you take ownership of your feelings. This empowers you to adopt healthier coping strategies.


How REBT Transforms Shoulding


Transforming "shoulds" into flexible preferences can significantly enhance your mental well-being. Here’s how REBT works its magic:


Step 1: Identifying the "Shoulds"


The journey begins by recognizing when you’re "shoulding" on yourself or others. Keep a journal to track these thoughts. Ask yourself:


  • When do I feel pressured or anxious?

  • What expectations am I placing on myself or others?


Identifying these triggers is the first step to meaningful change.


Step 2: Challenging the Beliefs


After identifying your "shoulds," it’s time to challenge them. Ask:


  • Is this belief rational?

  • Is there evidence supporting this "should"?

  • Are there alternative perspectives?


For example, instead of thinking, "I should be more productive," try, "I prefer to be more productive." This subtle language shift allows you to own your goals without self-inflicted guilt.


Step 3: Replacing "Should" with Preferences


A key goal of REBT is to substitute "should" statements with preferences. For instance, instead of saying, "I should go to the gym," consider saying, "I would like to go to the gym." This minor change makes your aspirations feel achievable rather than burdensome.


Step 4: Embracing Acceptance


Acceptance is a core aspect of REBT. Understand that you might not accomplish everything you wish, and that's perfectly fine! Accepting life's uncertainties allows you to forgive yourself and others.


Instead of lamenting what you "should" have done, focus on actionable steps you can take going forward. This shift will lead to a more optimistic outlook.


Benefits of Ditching "Shoulds"


The rewards of abandoning "shoulding" are profound:


Reduced Anxiety and Pressure


Letting go of "should" often results in noticeably lower anxiety and stress levels. You can free yourself from the guilt associated with unmet expectations, paving the way for more joy in daily life.


Improved Relationships


Reducing "your shoulds" regarding others can foster understanding and compassion in relationships. By replacing rigid expectations with flexibility, you promote meaningful communication and connection.


Enhanced Personal Growth


Focusing on preferences rather than demands encourages personal exploration. When you break free from "shoulds," you're more inclined to try new experiences and adapt positively.


Next Steps Towards a Lighthearted Approach


In a demanding world, it's easy to find yourself overwhelmed by "shoulds." However, by applying the principles of REBT, you can effectively reshape rigid beliefs into flexible preferences.


By recognizing, challenging, and replacing "shoulds," you can create a path toward a healthier, more rewarding life. So why not take action today? Let go of unnecessary pressures, embrace acceptance, and open yourself to greater freedom and growth.


Close-up view of a calm beach setting with gentle waves
A calming beach inviting reflection and peace.

With every mindful step you take to reduce "shoulding," you're likely to find more vibrancy and happiness in your life—free from the weight of unrealistic expectations. Remember, it's not just about avoiding "shoulds"; it's about celebrating choice and the possibilities life has to offer.

Comments


Brian Sharp Counseling LLC

© 2023 by Brian L. Sharp, LPC-S, LPC, LMHC, NCC - Proudly created with Wix.com

Please note that visiting or subscribing to Brian Sharp Counseling, LLC does not constitute a counseling relationship. By using this website, you agree to hold harmless Brian Sharp Counseling, LLC and its representatives from any liability in connection with any decisions you may make in connection with your use of this website. If you are currently experiencing a mental health emergency, please do not use this website and instead contact 911, 988 or your nearest hospital emergency room for assistance.

Online therapy and counseling services available in Texas, Florida, Connecticut and the United Kingdom

Note: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.​

bottom of page