top of page

Is 'Shoulding' on Yourself Making You Miserable? REBT Offers a Refreshing Perspective

Writer's picture: Brian SharpBrian Sharp

Have you ever found yourself caught in self-judgment, thinking things like, “I should exercise more” or “I should be more productive”? This tendency, known as "shoulding," seems innocent at first but can lead to feelings of guilt, frustration, and a habit of awfulizing—imagining the worst possible outcomes. If you've been feeling overwhelmed, you're not alone. A staggering 70% of adults experience stress from self-imposed expectations. But don’t worry! Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy (REBT) has effective strategies to help you escape this cycle.


In this blog post, we’ll explore the dangers of “shoulding” and how REBT can assist you in reframing negative thoughts, boosting your overall well-being, and paving a pathway to a more fulfilling life.


Understanding 'Shoulding' and Its Implications


What Is 'Shoulding'?


In simple terms, “shoulding” is when you hold yourself to unrealistic standards. Phrases like “I should be more successful” or “I shouldn’t make mistakes” create immense pressure. According to recent studies, 60% of individuals report feeling inadequate due to unmet expectations. Rather than motivating you, “shoulding” often leads to disappointment and anxiety.


The Pitfalls of Sorts


When you tell yourself that you “should” do something, it often spirals into feelings of dread. Imagine the pressure you feel when saying, “I should be going to the gym.” This kind of thinking creates emotional turbulence, causing you to feel worse about yourself and paralyzing your ability to act.


“Shoulding” doesn't merely lead to disappointment; it often evolves into awfulizing—a mental trap that makes situations seem worse than they actually are. For example, if you fail to complete a task, you may think, “I’m a total failure.” Such thoughts can lead to overthinking and emotional paralysis, preventing productive action.


Recognizing Awfulizing


Awfulizing occurs when negative thoughts turn into worst-case scenarios. After missing a deadline, you might think, “I’ll never succeed again!” This perspective ignores the reality that setbacks are often temporary and can lead to future opportunities.


Life is full of ups and downs. Research indicates that 80% of people face periodic disappointments yet continue to move forward. Recognizing that failure is a part of life helps to combat awfulizing.


REBT – A Tool for Change


What Is Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy?


Developed by Albert Ellis in the 1950s, Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy (REBT) is a type of cognitive-behavioral therapy focused on identifying and changing irrational beliefs. REBT teaches that you are not bound by rigid “shoulds.” Instead, you can learn to accept life's uncertainties and embrace imperfection.


Challenging Your 'Shoulds'


The cornerstone of REBT is challenging your irrational beliefs. Here’s how you can start dismantling your “should” statements:


  1. Identify Your Shoulds: Write down recurring “should” statements, like “I should be more organized” or “I should be happy all the time.”


  2. Ask Why: Examine why you hold these beliefs. Are they accurate, and are they constructive?


  3. Reframe into Preferences: Shift your language from “should” to “prefer.” Instead of saying, “I should exercise,” say, “I would prefer to exercise.” This minor change can relieve some pressure.


  4. Acceptance of Reality: Accept that not meeting expectations does not define your worth. Life is unpredictable, and that’s entirely normal.


Learning Through Acceptance


Embracing reality without harsh judgment is vital for emotional health. When you acknowledge your life as it is—recognizing both the good and the bad—you pave the way for self-acceptance. Research shows that self-acceptance is strongly linked to increased happiness and reduced anxiety.


Practical Tools to Manage ‘Shoulding’ and Awfulizing


1. Practice Mindfulness


Mindfulness helps you become aware of your thoughts without judgment. Techniques such as deep breathing, meditation, or yoga can interrupt cycles of “shoulding” and awfulizing, fostering a greater sense of calm. Studies show that practicing mindfulness can reduce anxiety levels by up to 50%.


2. Focus on What You Can Control


Redirect your attention from uncontrollable expectations to what you can manage. Engage in actions that reflect your values and authentic self, rather than arbitrary standards set by yourself or others.


3. Reassess Your Goals


Are your goals realistic? Restructuring larger goals into smaller, achievable steps can make tasks feel less daunting and help maintain your motivation. For instance, rather than aiming to run a marathon immediately, consider starting with a short walk or jog.


4. Seek Support


Sharing your feelings with friends or a mental health professional can provide fresh perspectives and lessen emotional burdens. A 2022 survey found that 78% of people who sought support reported feeling better after sharing their thoughts.


Challenging Common Misbeliefs


As you work to combat "shoulding," challenge the misconceptions that often fuel them. Here are a few:


Misbelief 1: “I must not fail.”


Failure is a natural part of growth. Embracing setbacks as learning opportunities allows you to develop resilience and can often lead to greater success in the future.


Misbelief 2: “If I don’t achieve my goals, I’m a failure.”


Your worth is not tied to achievements. Regardless of productivity, you remain valuable and deserving of respect.


Misbelief 3: “Others are judging me for my shortcomings.”


Most people are preoccupied with their challenges, meaning they are unlikely to scrutinize your actions closely. Focusing on perceived judgment can hinder your ability to live authentically.


Embracing Your Journey


"Shoulding" and awfulizing can significantly impact your mental clarity and emotional well-being. By recognizing these patterns and using strategies from Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy, you can reshape your mindset. Accepting the reality of life and letting go of rigid expectations opens the door to a more fulfilling existence.


Remember, it's okay to release the "shoulds." You don't have to be perfect or meet every self-imposed demand. Allow yourself the freedom to live authentically, understanding that hurdles and imperfections are essential parts of your unique journey.


Eye-level view of a person standing by a serene lake, reflecting on life.
A moment of reflection by a serene lake, contemplating the realities of life.

As you embark on this journey of redefining your relationship with your thoughts, take a moment to breathe deeply. Appreciate where you are and embrace the beauty of being imperfectly you. Life is full of surprises, and accepting unpredictability often leads to its most rewarding moments.

0 views0 comments

Comments


Brian Sharp Counseling LLC

© 2023 by Brian L. Sharp, LPC-S, LPC, LMHC, NCC - Proudly created with Wix.com

Please note that visiting or subscribing to Brian Sharp Counseling, LLC does not constitute a counseling relationship. By using this website, you agree to hold harmless Brian Sharp Counseling, LLC and its representatives from any liability in connection with any decisions you may make in connection with your use of this website. If you are currently experiencing a mental health emergency, please do not use this website and instead contact 911, 988 or your nearest hospital emergency room for assistance.

Online therapy and counseling services available in Texas, Florida, Connecticut and the United Kingdom

Note: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.​

bottom of page